The coming of the first settlers, Fifty years Ago by Dr. Eben D. Pierce

Witness Tree Remnant

The Arcadia Area Historical Society received a section of the "Witness Tree" in the Spring to 2000. This tree was removed from the Prosper Schank Farm and donated by the Richard Schank Family.

Fifty years ago Arcadia was awakeneed from a dream of wilderness, by a party of pioneers who came from far and wide to seek homes in the Valley of Trempealeau.

Collin Bishop, George Shelley and James Broughton had made the journey by team form Southern Wisconsin to Fountain City, driving with them a herd of fifteen cattle. At La Crosse they learned of the vacant land located in the town of Preston, which then inclued the present town of Arcadia.

A few weeks were spent at Fountain City, during which time Mr. Bishop took some swamp and state land. But the desire to visit the large tract of vacant land in the Treampealeau Valley still possessed the minds of the homeseekers, and on an autumn morning just half a century ago they set out afoot for the new country.

The party was composed of Collins Bishop, George Dewey, George Shelly and James Broughton and they followed an old Indian trail, over which the Indians used to travel from the Mississippi to the Black River.

They hit the trail with eager feet for their hopes were high, and before them drifted visions of future homes of peace and plenty.

Over hills and through valleys across streams and through dimpling meadows of wild grass they workd their way and in a few hours the Glencoe Ridge was reached. Here they were overtaken by a lone footman, who was also looking for land. Their new companion was Noah Comstock, a tried and faithful pioneer who brought with him the experience of a "Forty-Niner" and whose knowledge of surveying was a valuable aid to the land seekers.

The party journeyed on and soon arrives at the home of George Cowie, where they remained all night. Early the next morning they set out for their destination, and inspired by the fresh autumn air and the exhileration of adventure the distance to the Trempealeau River was soon covered.

When the river was reached they drew cuts to see who would wade the stream and find a fording place. This was easily accomplished for the water was only a little more than knee deep and a fording place was found just a short distance from where the bridge now stands.

From the river to the hill they followed an Indian trail that lead over nearly the same ground where our Main Street is now located. When the summit of the hill was reached, a tree was sighted and owning to the scarcity of trees the land hunters decided to examine it for a bearing tree. They were disappointed for when they came to the oak it proved to be just what they had anticapated, and not far from it was a hole in the ground which after examining Mr. Comstock concluded was a section post mark.

The day was spent in looking over the new country and examining its soil, and general features with a vew of loaating. At night the nen returned to Mr. Cowie's home and the next day they came back prepared to take each a quarter section of land and select a favorable building spot. This done they returned to Fountain City well satisfied with the prospect's of the new country.

Late in the fall Collins Bishop hired James Broughton and Mr. Davis to build a house on his quarter-section. They erected the building near the bearing treee, the site chosen by Mr Bishop and used logs for the main part with boards for the roof. This was the first house erected in Arcadia, and some of the boards from the old cabin are still doing good service on Mr Bishop's barn in East Arcadia. The old oak under which the cabin was built still stands, a majestic landmark and rustic monument commemorating the coming of the first settlers, fifty years ago.

The next spring Mr. Bishop came over to his new home and broke several acres of land. This was the first land cultivated in Arcadia, and the crop gathered in the fall was encouraging to the infant farming settlement.

During the spring and summer other settlers came and by winter several house had been built and the little community had developed far enough to make itself known to the world. The settlers requestd by petition to the county board that Preston be divided and a new town formed. This was in 1856 and it now became necessary to decide on a name for the new town.

Previous ot htis time it was know as Bishop's Settlement and some called to Barn Town on account of the number of barms erected by the early settlers.

The petition regarding the formation of a new town was granted, and so one winter day the pioneer neighbors met at Mr Bishop's cabin for the purpose of nameing the town. The women were give the privilege to name it and Mrs. David Bishop (Mrs. Chas Mercer) offered the name Arcadia, which had been suggested by Noah Comstock.

Arcadia with its brand new name grew steadily and with the growth came the inevitable changes that have made the world wonder at our western mode of rapid development.

It might be interesting to know how mistakes are responsible for the nameing of two of our prominent bluffs.

To be brief - Noah Comstock's mistake in regard to the section postmark in the ground near the old bearing tree gave him a bluff in East Arcadia. He was not compelled to retain the quarter section contain this waste of land, but ever since the mistake was discoverd the bluff has been called by his given name, "Noah's Bluff".

Barn's Bluff was called Gage's Barn until the railroad was built, when it was change to its present name. Mr Gage on his way across the hills from Treampealeau on a moonlight night saw in the distance what he supposed to be a barn, and on arriving at Mr. Bishop's house he told of what he had seen, and wanted to know whose barn it was that attracted his attention, and caused him to turn toward the lighted cabin window, where he found a hearty welcome within. From that day until the railroad come the bluff was called Gage's Barn.

Few towns of our age and size have in their possession the original first settler, and we should feel proud to have in our midst the venerable pioneer who saw the dawn of Arcadia, and who helped to pave the way to our present prosperous condition. He still tills the soil on the old place he took as a home fifty years ago, and although the snowy hand of winter has touched his brow he still possesses a clear and active mind that reflect the wholesomeness of a full orbed life. His fibre is akin to the old oak under which he reared the first cabin in the town and with a memory rich in all the wide variety of interesting events of life he enjoys recounting the experiences of the pioneer days gone by. He is the last of the first settlers and in looking back over the departed years he can see the great contrast between the early awakening of the little settlement and the progressive and modernly equipped town of today.

The dream of the pioneer has been more than realized. He has seen our country change from a favorite hunting ground of the Indian, to a rich agricultural land, from a low marshy swamp, to a beautiful and prosperous village, from a wilderness, to a populous community, where there is an abundance, and where instead of barren hills and valleys in a wild state of nature we have the cozy homes of a contented people, nestled among the woodlands, where silence has departed and left in her stead, the song of the housewife and plowboy

(The Arcadian , Friday, October 5, 1905, Page 1)